Orion Quin
Orion Quin  ·  Inquiry  ·  The Everyday Road 10/12

Small Against the Land

One of the genuinely reliable effects of moving through large landscapes, with a research literature that is modest and real.


Scale · Ego  ·  ~5 min read

Awe is the feeling of being in the presence of something vast that transcends current understanding.Dacher Keltner and Jonathan Haidt’s working definition

§ 01The Effect

Most people have had it

Move through big country for long enough and something happens to the size of your concerns. The thing you were turning over at the trailhead is still there at the top and it has changed proportion.

This is not a technique and it is not available on demand. It is closer to a side effect of exposure: sustained time in a landscape large enough to be indifferent to you.

What it seems to do is loosen the grip of self-focus for a while. And the odd part, which most people report, is that being made small is a relief rather than an insult.

§ 02The Research

Modest, replicated reasonably

Awe research has found that experiences of vastness are associated with a diminished sense of self-importance — what the literature calls the small self — and with increases in prosocial behaviour in some experiments.5 The effects are modest, the manipulations are often laboratory approximations of vastness, and the field has had its share of replication questions.

The quiet-ego and humility literature points the same way: lower self-focus is associated with better relationships and, in several studies, with better learning, since a person less occupied with their own standing has more attention available for the thing itself.4

And the burden-of-self-focus argument is worth having: chronic self-attention is effortful, and a good deal of what people experience as mental fatigue is the maintenance of a self-image nobody else is checking.8

What smallness gives back
Fig.01 · The relief nobody expects
The concerns do not shrink because they were unimportant. They shrink because something has restored their proportion.
The inflated version
your importance, carried · effortful · and nobody is checking
→
Made small
the concern still there, at its actual size
→
What is freed
attention, mostly — which is the practical benefit
Being made small turns out to be a relief.
Framework: awe and the small self · the quiet ego · the cost of self-focus

§ 03Where It Stops Working

Two limits

The first: some things do not shrink, and should not. Grief does not respond to a big view, and neither does a serious injustice. A landscape that puts your work worries in proportion will not do anything for a bereavement, and the disappointment of discovering that is its own small cruelty.

The second: smallness can shade into insignificance, which is a different feeling with a different valence. The useful version puts your concerns in proportion. The unhelpful version says nothing you do matters, and for some people in some states, the vast indifferent landscape delivers the second rather than the first.

Which means this is not a technique to prescribe. It is an effect to be available to, and to notice whether you are getting.

§ 04Doing It

Go somewhere big

Almost entirely about exposure rather than attitude.

01
Get somewhere large periodically, on purpose
Water, mountains, sky, distance. The effect needs actual vastness and does not happen on a treadmill.
02
Stay long enough it is not immediate
The proportion shift takes a while. Short exposures mostly produce a nice view.
03
Let it happen rather than pursuing it the usual rule
Arriving determined to feel awe is a reliable way not to.
04
Notice which version you got proportion, or insignificance
They feel similar for a moment and diverge quickly. If it is the second, that is worth attending to.
05
Do not prescribe it to the grieving it does not work on that
Some things do not shrink, and offering this as a remedy for them is a small cruelty.

§ 05Sources

This series discusses running practices belonging to specific Indigenous nations of the Americas. Where a practice belongs to a named people, it is named; where a source is an Indigenous author, runner or organization speaking publicly about their own tradition, that is said. Ceremonial and religious specifics that those nations have not made public are not discussed here and are not the author’s to convert into technique. General claims about running physiology and psychology are cited by author and publication, with links where a stable public page exists.

  1. The author — the observation about scale and self-focus is the author’s, argued from the awe and quiet-ego research cited below.
  2. Keltner, D. et al. — awe and the small self, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (2015). Vastness diminishing self-importance and nourishing the person.
  3. Bauer, J. & Wayment, H. — Transcending Self-Interest: The Quiet Ego (2008). The quieter, less self-focused ego and well-being.
  4. Tangney, June — humility as a strength, Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology (2000). Humility as genuine strength, not weakness.
  5. Piff, P. et al. — awe, the small self, and prosociality, JPSP (2015). The nourishing effects of feeling small before the vast.
  6. Sedikides, C. — on the costs of the inflated ego and narcissism. Self-importance as burden and hindrance.
  7. Nabokov, Peter — Indian Running (1981). Humility and the runner's place in a larger whole.
  8. Leary, Mark — The Curse of the Self (2004). The burden of the self-focused ego and the freedom of quieting it.
§   T H E   T A K E A W A Y

Sustained time in large country loosens self-focus and restores the proportion of things — a modest, reasonably replicated effect, and a relief rather than an insult.

But grief does not shrink, injustice should not, and smallness can tip into insignificance. This is an effect to be available to, not a remedy to hand anybody.

The Everyday Road · 10 of 12  ·  the whole series  ·  all collections