Orion Quin
Orion Quin  ·  Inquiry  ·  The Everyday Practice 8/12

The Heroic North: Meeting What’s Coming

Twelve essays on a body of literature rather than a doctrine, written down by Christians centuries after the world it describes.


The Heroic North  ·  ~5 min read

Fate goes ever as it must.Beowulf, trans. Seamus Heaney

§ 01Where It Starts

With texts that are not what they look like

Everything here arrives through writings set down in Christian societies long after the pagan world they depict. The Poetic Edda survives in a thirteenth-century Icelandic manuscript; the sagas were composed two or three centuries after their events; Snorri, who gave us the most systematic account of Norse myth, was a Christian chieftain writing a handbook for poets.

So this is literature about a past rather than a record of a faith, and “the heroes believed” means the texts portray them believing.

Two facts about that past belong at the front: it was a slave-holding society funded substantially by raiding, and its honour system was a membership rule — elaborate courtesy between men of standing, very little restraint outside that circle.

§ 02The One Thing Worth Taking

Going forward with the fear present

The literature is unembarrassed about dread. Its people sweat before fights, hesitate at doors and go pale, described by narrators who plainly do not think less of them for it.

What gets singled out is not the absence of the feeling but the step taken while it is there, which relocates courage from a temperament to an act — and an act is available to anyone.

The sturdier research alongside it is about reappraisal: reading the physical signs of stress as mobilization rather than as a verdict has shown modest effects on performance and physiology. The suppression literature is a laboratory pattern whose transfer to real fear is a further step.

Waiting to be fearless
  • Courage as a temperament you have or lack
  • The feeling read as a verdict on readiness
  • Effort spent on not feeling it
  • The step deferred until a condition that rarely arrives
Going forward with it
  • Courage as an act, available to anyone
  • The feeling read as mobilization, which it partly is
  • Effort spent on the act
  • The step taken while the fear is present

Not the absence of fear. The step taken while it is there.

§ 03Where It Fails

The symbols in current use

Norse and Germanic heroic imagery is heavily used in white-nationalist iconography. That is an unavoidable modern context for this material — not the only one, since the same symbols are in ordinary use by practising heathens, scholars, Icelanders and across a good deal of mainstream culture, but not something to write around either.

There is no ethnic content in anything the collection draws from these texts. The idea of a pure Germanic inheritance is a nineteenth-century invention with a twentieth-century use, and Icelandic scholars and heathen groups have objected to the appropriation for decades.

The literature also supplies no help at all with when the fear is correct, and it admires a great many men who could not decline a challenge and died of it.

Note — the predictable misuse

Far-right appropriation is an unavoidable modern context for this material.

Present and active rather than a historical curiosity, and not the only context. Writing admiringly about northern heroic virtue without saying so produces something adjacent to a body of material worth wanting no part of.

§ 04Doing It

Ask, then step

A filter first, because the literature will not supply one.

01
Ask whether the fear is information before anything
If it is, act on the information. This filter is what separates courage from what kills saga characters.
02
Take the step with it present rather than waiting
The going is the courage. Waiting for the feeling to pass is waiting for a condition that mostly does not arrive.
03
Name who depends on your holding specifically
The shield-wall effect runs on a particular person, not an abstraction. Visible dependence is the operative variable.
04
Sort the hardship before enduring it escapable, or not?
Grinding through is for suffering that is unavoidable and has an end. Applied elsewhere it is a machine for damage.
05
Notice which endings you can see coming and meet those
Most last times are identified only afterwards.

§ 05Sources

This guide introduces eleven collections and does not restate their citations; each essay points at the ring it summarizes, where the sources and their limits are set out in full. Sources listed here are those bearing on the cross-tradition claims made in this collection alone, with links where a stable public page exists.

  1. The Poetic Edda — esp. the Hávamál and Völuspá. Trans. Jackson Crawford; Carolyne Larrington; Henry Adams Bellows. The northern wisdom of fate, courage, the deed, and Ragnarök — the spine of the series.
  2. Snorri Sturluson — The Prose Edda. Trans. Jesse Byock. The fullest telling of the myths, including the gods' last stand.
  3. The Icelandic Sagas — Njál's Saga, Egil's Saga, and others. Penguin Classics editions. Fate, oath, honor, endurance, and the good end, lived.
  4. Beowulf — trans. Seamus Heaney; Maria Dahvana Headley. The forward heart, the mead-hall, the shield-wall, and the old king's good end.
  5. Homer — The Iliad. Trans. Lattimore; Fagles. Kleos and the worthy foe — the Homeric heroic register alongside the Norse.
  6. Tolkien, J. R. R. — “The Monsters and the Critics” (1936). The northern “theory of courage” — the will to fight on against certain defeat.
  7. Miller, W. I. — Bloodtaking and Peacemaking (1990) and related works. Drengskapr, the oath, and the honor-culture of the north.
  8. The twelve meditations — Wyrd · The Heart That Goes Forward · The Deed That Never Dies · The Shield-Wall · The Oath · The Last Stand · The Ring-Giver · The Grim Endurance · The Worthy Foe · The Fury and the Rein · The Saga You Leave · The Good End. And the supporting sciences cited within each — approached, throughout, as a student.
§   T H E   T A K E A W A Y

Courage relocated from a temperament to an act: the step taken while the fear is present, which is available to anyone.

And the literature supplies no way to tell when the fear is correct. Its symbols are also in heavy current use by movements worth wanting no part of, which the collection states at the entrance.

The Everyday Practice · 8 of 12  ·  the whole series  ·  all collections